Letter: Vaccine wrong answer to Lyme disease

The Associated Press article "Major test of first possible Lyme shot in decades starts," Aug. 9, described testing of a possible new vaccine to prevent Lyme disease. This sounds like a good idea, but it isn't. Ticks carry many other diseases, such as Powassan, Babesiosis and more.

Most of these are transmitted quickly when the tick bites, not after a long delay like Lyme. Being vaccinated against Lyme will make people complacent about ticks, and thus more likely to catch a different tick-borne disease.

In the woods today, it is important to never get bitten by a tick in the first place. This can be accomplished by smearing your body and your clothes with DEET, but there is a better answer: permethrin.

Permethrin is applied to clothing and allowed to dry before wearing. Commercially treated garments are good for 70 washings, and the ones you spray at home are good for 6 washings before you need to re-treat them. As a bonus, permethrin also works against mosquitos and many other bugs.

It is proven effective, but is it safe? Well, permethrin is approved for topical use against lice, including in children. To my way of thinking, if it is safe enough to apply a 1 percent solution (such as Nix) directly to the skin of children, then applying a 0.5 percent solution (such as Sawyer permethrin spray) to my clothing and letting it dry before wearing is going to be OK.

I am a supporter of vaccines in general, but not this one.

Worth Gretter

Menands

आप यहां पूरा लेख पढ़ सकते हैं।

टाइम्स यूनियन: पत्र: लाइम रोग के लिए वैक्सीन गलत जवाब

American bald eagle with wings spread holding a shield with stars and stripes and banners above.
American bald eagle with wings spread holding a shield with stars and stripes and banners above.

Letter: Vaccine wrong answer to Lyme disease

The Associated Press article "Major test of first possible Lyme shot in decades starts," Aug. 9, described testing of a possible new vaccine to prevent Lyme disease. This sounds like a good idea, but it isn't. Ticks carry many other diseases, such as Powassan, Babesiosis and more.

Most of these are transmitted quickly when the tick bites, not after a long delay like Lyme. Being vaccinated against Lyme will make people complacent about ticks, and thus more likely to catch a different tick-borne disease.

In the woods today, it is important to never get bitten by a tick in the first place. This can be accomplished by smearing your body and your clothes with DEET, but there is a better answer: permethrin.

Permethrin is applied to clothing and allowed to dry before wearing. Commercially treated garments are good for 70 washings, and the ones you spray at home are good for 6 washings before you need to re-treat them. As a bonus, permethrin also works against mosquitos and many other bugs.

It is proven effective, but is it safe? Well, permethrin is approved for topical use against lice, including in children. To my way of thinking, if it is safe enough to apply a 1 percent solution (such as Nix) directly to the skin of children, then applying a 0.5 percent solution (such as Sawyer permethrin spray) to my clothing and letting it dry before wearing is going to be OK.

I am a supporter of vaccines in general, but not this one.

Worth Gretter

Menands

आप यहां पूरा लेख पढ़ सकते हैं।

फोटो थंबनेल ब्लॉग लेखक
News Organization
टाइम्स यूनियन
The Times Union is the leading news organization in New York’s Capital Region.
मीडिया मेंशन

टाइम्स यूनियन: पत्र: लाइम रोग के लिए वैक्सीन गलत जवाब

American bald eagle with wings spread holding a shield with stars and stripes and banners above.
American bald eagle with wings spread holding a shield with stars and stripes and banners above.

Letter: Vaccine wrong answer to Lyme disease

The Associated Press article "Major test of first possible Lyme shot in decades starts," Aug. 9, described testing of a possible new vaccine to prevent Lyme disease. This sounds like a good idea, but it isn't. Ticks carry many other diseases, such as Powassan, Babesiosis and more.

Most of these are transmitted quickly when the tick bites, not after a long delay like Lyme. Being vaccinated against Lyme will make people complacent about ticks, and thus more likely to catch a different tick-borne disease.

In the woods today, it is important to never get bitten by a tick in the first place. This can be accomplished by smearing your body and your clothes with DEET, but there is a better answer: permethrin.

Permethrin is applied to clothing and allowed to dry before wearing. Commercially treated garments are good for 70 washings, and the ones you spray at home are good for 6 washings before you need to re-treat them. As a bonus, permethrin also works against mosquitos and many other bugs.

It is proven effective, but is it safe? Well, permethrin is approved for topical use against lice, including in children. To my way of thinking, if it is safe enough to apply a 1 percent solution (such as Nix) directly to the skin of children, then applying a 0.5 percent solution (such as Sawyer permethrin spray) to my clothing and letting it dry before wearing is going to be OK.

I am a supporter of vaccines in general, but not this one.

Worth Gretter

Menands

आप यहां पूरा लेख पढ़ सकते हैं।

फोटो थंबनेल ब्लॉग लेखक
News Organization
टाइम्स यूनियन
The Times Union is the leading news organization in New York’s Capital Region.
मीडिया मेंशन
browse all articles
यहाँ सॉयर में

Recent mentions

Close-up of a small tick crawling on the edge of a textured green leaf.
MSN: Warmer Winter Could Lead To An Increase In Ticks
As more Northern Nevadans head outdoors this spring and summer, experts say hikers should be aware of a small pest that can cause big problems — ticks.
View post
Close-up of a small tick crawling on beige fabric outdoors with blurred green and brown background.
Yahoo! Health: How To Protect Yourself From Ticks This Season, According To Experts
What experts say you should do before — and after — heading outdoors.
View post
Couple sitting on floor behind laid out backpacks and organized camping and hiking gear.
The Trek: Going Gaga Over Gear
Your life in a backpack? Yes, it’s possible.
View post
Various insect repellent products on a wooden shelf including sprays, lotion, and citronella candle.
REI: How to Choose Insect Repellent
Find the right bug spray for you based on the active ingredient, concentration and application type.
View post
Muddy ground with animal and tire tracks and a single green leaf near the bottom center.
Upland Almanac: Average Joe
That deep desire to get outside after a long, cold winter is what elevates turkey hunting here in the Northeast to a premier pursuit.
View post
A small black sprinkler head in the middle of a green backyard lawn with plants blurred in foreground.
AOL: Keeping Summer Pests At Bay: Tips To Protect Your Home
As the summer season returns, uninvited guests make their way into our homes.
View post
Backpacker seated on a log drinking from a water bladder in a grassy field with pine trees behind.
Backpacker: RIP To These Bygone Backpacking Trends
Take a hike down memory lane to celebrate the gear and fads that got backpacking to where it is today.
View post